Please Don’t Ask Me How I Am: Suzanne Vega’s Luka


Who can forget the first four notes of Suzanne Vega’s classic song “Luka”? Clear and clean, they chime brightly into existence, simultaneously creating and filling a void that collapses as soon as Vega’s sunny guitar ripples in. Musically, it’s absolutely lovely and a real feather in Vegas’s cap, becoming one of the top-selling singles of 1987.

Not so Hidden Meaning

               But behind the mellow timbre and gently upbeat tempo, there’s a darkness at the core of “Luka”. It’s a darkness that, to her credit, Vega never tries to obscure. The subject of the song is child abuse, the abuse of the titular Luka specifically (who also narrates), and the lyrics couldn’t be clearer. For a choice example, try “they only hit ‘til you cry/after that, you don’t ask why”. It’s brutal and direct but absolutely touched with a respect for Luka’s humanity.

That said, Vega doesn’t just wallop the listener upside the head with Luka’s abuse. Instead, she eases us in with a few lines dedicated to Luka’s self-introduction that turn ominous when he suddenly announces “if you hear something late at night/some kind of troublesome kind of fright/just don’t ask me what it was”. It’s a nice little trail of breadcrumbs leading us up the proverbial garden path. But it doesn’t just make the reveal all the more impactful, it also ensures we get to know Luka as a person before we learn about the more insalubrious aspects of his life.   

Realisitc Consequences   

               Those aspects also include the way Luka conceals his abuse from others. “Yes, I think I’m okay/walked into the door again/if you ask, that’s what I’ll say/ and it’s not your business anyway” is the lengthiest. But through the song, Luka asks the listener not to inquire. This mirrors the real-life behavior of many victims of abuse, who cover for their abusers because they either fear the potential consequences or don’t want their abuser to get in trouble.  

 As far as depictions of abuse in media go, “Luka” remains one of the most realistic. It’s matter-of-fact treatment of its subject, with little in the way of melodrama, plus its total honesty make it a classic.

Real-Life Inspiration

Interestingly though, the song’s genesis was far removed from the subject of child abuse. Instead, Vega’s initial inspiration for the song came from a child she once saw on the streets of New York. Suzanne Vega has always been keen observer with an eye for relationships, and she used those abilities to their best effect here. According to no less than the woman herself, she would often see the same group of children playing in the street. One child, in particular, caught her eye, a boy named Luka.

Luka never really seemed a part of the group. He was always separate somehow, isolated. More than that, something just seemed inherently different about the boy. Though, Vega could never quite put her finger on what. Either way, he made an impression on her.

Later, when Vega wanted to write a song about child abuse, Luka came back to her. Conceptually, it was a lot like one of Joseph Cornell’s assemblages. Vega took two things that were destined to be together, even if only she recognized that and made them so. The only real difference being that “Luka” is a fusion of idea and memory rather than the bric-a-brac Cornell used.  

Enduring Classic

“Luka” is a fine song, and a testament to Suzanne Vega’s prowess as a songwriter, tackling a difficult subject elegantly and honestly.  It’s also a modern folk classic, up there with Tracey Chapman’s “Fast Car” and a worthy addition to any music collection. While it’s getting on in years, it remains as relevant as ever, a gentle reminder of the darker aspects of life.   


Leave a Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.